Despite common advice otherwise, staying put is often the fastest way up.
The Wharton School’s Matthew Bidwell had an interesting piece in the The Wall Street Journal last week looking at the data behind the idea that job hopping is the best way to advance your career. People are often told that switching jobs is the fastest way to advance and grow your paycheck, but research is increasingly showing this isn’t the case:
1. MBA alumni who moved within a firm nearly doubled the number of people they managed. Those who changed firms typically managed the same number as before.
2. In a study of nearly 60,000 workers in Finland, a meaningful promotion was almost six times more likely through an internal move. External job moves tended to be lateral moves.
3. Data from the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth shows that people who move jobs more frequently between their mid-20s and mid-30s are earning less in their mid-30s compared to their peers, even when controlling for other variables (education, gender, ethnicity, etc.). This is backed up by numerous other research studies over the last few decades which show that people who stay longer at companies tend to earn more.
4. In a study of top executives conducted by The Wharton School and IE University in Spain, 74% got their roles from inside the company – a number that’s pretty similar to what my colleagues and I have found when we’ve looked at the data as part of research studies at Russell Reynolds Associates. In fact, a few years back, when we looked at CEOs at the world’s top companies, the largest group of CEOs had been at their company for between 11-20 years prior to appointment.
Bidwell points out that what is overlooked in the advice to move jobs to advance your career is the reality that new employees often take two to three years to establish themselves, build strong relationships, and understand the organization well enough to perform highly. The people who move up internally – including those CEOs we looked at – have “insider advantage”: they know the people, the organization, the products/services, and the customers. They likely also know what’s working and what needs to change. From what I have seen over my career, their time from role transition to high performance is much, much faster.
This doesn’t mean that you should never move around. Your work conditions might be terrible, or your pay might be far under what the market says is fair. You may also simply not have a path up in your organization for any number of reasons. In those situations, make a move to set yourself up for success – but for the sake of your career, when you pick where you’re going to land next, do it with an eye toward being there a while.
